Portfolio Overlap: Too Many Funds, Same Stocks

Short answer: Owning many mutual funds does not always spread your risk. If your funds hold the same shares, your money sits in the same few companies. This is called portfolio overlap. Real diversification comes from different holdings, not from more funds. So check the holdings before you add another fund.

Key Facts

  • Overlap between two funds is the sum of the smaller weight of each common stock. SEBI uses this same method in its circular dated 26 February 2026.
  • That SEBI circular caps overlap at 50% for sectoral and thematic funds against other equity schemes, except large cap schemes.
  • A large cap fund must keep at least 80% of its money in large cap companies. These are the top 100 listed companies by full market value.
  • For FY 2026-27, equity fund gains are taxed at 20% if you sell within 12 months. After 12 months, gains above ₹1.25 lakh a year are taxed at 12.5%.
  • As per AMFI data, investors put ₹32,160 crore into SIPs in October 2026. A Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) means you invest a fixed amount every month.

Last updated: 13 November 2026

Do you hold five mutual funds? Many investors feel safe with that number. They think five funds mean five separate baskets. But what if all five baskets carry the same eggs?

A mutual fund collects money from many people and buys shares with it. Two funds can buy the same shares. When that happens, your risk is not spread. It only looks spread.

This guide shows the problem with simple numbers. All funds and stocks in the examples are made up. You will also get five clear steps to fix it.

Do More Funds Mean More Diversification?

No. Diversification means spreading your money across different things. The number of funds does not decide it. The difference between their holdings decides it.

PointFive funds of the same styleFour funds with different roles
What they holdMostly the same big companiesDifferent types, like large cap, mid cap, debt and gold
Spread of riskLow. One bad stock hurts every fundBetter. Each part moves in its own way
OverlapOften highUsually low
Work to trackMore statements, more reviewsLess, and each fund has a clear job

Who wrote this guide? Deepak Gokul holds the CWM® certification. He is NISM-Series-XVII: Retirement Adviser Certified and an IRDAI Licensed Insurance Advisor. His firm, Deepak Wealth Framework Pvt Ltd, is AMFI Registered as a Mutual Fund Distributor. He has over 19 years of experience. We checked every rule here against SEBI, AMFI and Income Tax sources in November 2026.

Why Do Investors End Up With Too Many Funds?

There are two common reasons.

  • Chasing lists. You see a “top performer” list and buy one more fund.
  • Fear. You feel that putting all your money in one fund is risky.

So the count grows to six or eight funds. But many of them hold the same big shares. Your risk does not fall much. Only your tracking work goes up.

How Do You Calculate Portfolio Overlap?

First, one term. The weight of a stock is its share in the fund’s total money. If a fund keeps 9% of its money in one bank, that bank’s weight is 9%.

The method has three steps.

  1. List the stocks that both funds hold.
  2. For each common stock, take the smaller of the two weights.
  3. Add up these smaller weights. The total is the overlap.

SEBI regulates mutual funds in India.

A Worked Example With Three Made-Up Funds

The table shows the top 10 holdings of three made-up funds. The numbers are weights in percent.

StockFund 1Fund 2Fund 3
Bank A9812
Bank B769
IT Co A656
Oil Co A648
FMCG Co A434
Auto Co A3.543.5
Telecom Co A3.5Nil4.5
Bank C32.53
IT Co B324
Pharma Co A2.53Nil
Industrial Co ANil2.5Nil
Infra Co ANilNil3.5
Top 10 total47.54057.5

Now compare Fund 1 and Fund 2. Bank A is 9% in one and 8% in the other. So we take 8%. Do the same for the other eight common stocks.

The sum is 8 + 6 + 5 + 4 + 3 + 3.5 + 2.5 + 2 + 2.5. That gives 36.5%.

Pair of fundsOverlap (top 10 only)
Fund 1 and Fund 236.5%
Fund 1 and Fund 345%
Fund 2 and Fund 334%

Please note: This uses only the top 10 holdings. The full portfolio can give a higher or lower number. Treat a top 10 check as a first look, not the final answer.

What Does This Mean in Rupees?

Take a made-up investor, Revathi, aged 35. She runs SIPs of ₹20,000 a month across five funds.

Eight stocks appear in all three funds above. Bank A alone has an average weight of about 9.7%. Say Revathi puts ₹5,000 a month into each of these three funds. Then about ₹1,450 of that ₹15,000 goes into Bank A alone.

So if Bank A falls, all three funds feel it together.

Does Overlap Cost You Money?

Overlap does not add a fee by itself. But every fund has an expense ratio. This is the yearly cost the fund takes from your money, shown in percent. Since 1 April 2026, its main part is called the Base Expense Ratio (BER).

Some duplicate funds cost more than others. Over many years, a small cost gap becomes a big rupee gap.

₹20,000 monthly SIP for 15 yearsAssumed yearly returnValue at the end
Lower-cost portfolio12%About ₹95.19 lakh
Portfolio with 0.6% more yearly cost11.4%About ₹90.44 lakh
DifferenceAbout ₹4.75 lakh

Revathi invests ₹36 lakh in total in both cases. The 12% return and the 0.6% gap are only assumptions. Returns are not guaranteed. Your own funds’ expense ratios are the real numbers to check.

Is All Overlap Bad?

No. Some overlap is natural. A large cap fund must keep at least 80% of its money in large cap companies. Large cap companies are the top 100 listed companies by full market value. So two large cap funds will often hold the same names.

SEBI now watches overlap too. Its 2026 circular sets a 50% limit for sectoral and thematic funds. These funds invest in one industry or one idea. The limit applies against other equity schemes, except large cap schemes.

Fund houses must also show category-wise overlap levels on their websites every month. But this rule is for fund houses. It does not limit your own mix of funds.

Should You Sell Duplicate Funds at Once?

No. Please do not rush. Selling can bring two costs.

  • Capital gains tax. This is tax on your profit. For equity funds in FY 2026-27, the rate is 20% within 12 months. After 12 months, gains above ₹1.25 lakh a year are taxed at 12.5%.
  • Exit load. This is a small fee some funds charge if you sell early. Check your scheme’s document for the exact rule.

So start with the easy step. Stop the new SIP in the duplicate fund. Stopping a SIP is not a sale, so it brings no tax. Then move the old money in stages, after checking the tax. Our guide on mutual fund taxation in India explains the rates.

How Can You Check Your Own Overlap?

You have three ways.

  1. Read the factsheet. A factsheet is a monthly report from the fund house. It lists the top holdings. Learn how to read a mutual fund factsheet.
  2. Use an online overlap tool. These tools compare full portfolios. But match their data with the factsheet before you trust the result.
  3. Ask a professional. Your mutual fund distributor or adviser can run the check for you.

One working guide: if the same stock shows up in more than three of your funds, look closer. This is not an official limit.

Five Steps to Fix Too Many Funds

  1. Write down every fund with its SIP amount.
  2. Write one goal next to each fund.
  3. Compare the top 10 holdings of your funds.
  4. Stop new SIPs in duplicate funds of the same style.
  5. Before you sell, check tax and exit load. Then fix a date and shift in stages.

One test helps. Can you say in one line why you hold each fund? If not, review that fund. Our earlier guide explains what mutual fund portfolio overlap is in more detail.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is five mutual funds too many?

Not always. The number matters less than what the funds hold. Five funds with different roles can work well. Five funds of the same style often hold the same shares. Then you get more paperwork, but not more safety. Ask one question for each fund: why is it here?

How do I calculate overlap between two mutual funds?

Take the list of holdings of both funds. Find the stocks present in both. For each common stock, note the smaller weight. Add these smaller weights. The total is the overlap percentage. SEBI describes this same method in its circular dated 26 February 2026.

Is a top 10 overlap check enough?

No. The top 10 holdings show only one part of each fund. The full portfolio can give a higher or lower number. Use the top 10 as a quick first check. For a proper answer, compare the full monthly portfolios that fund houses publish on their websites.

Does SEBI’s 50% overlap limit apply to my own portfolio?

No. The limit applies to fund houses, not to investors. It covers sectoral and thematic schemes against other equity schemes, except large cap schemes. It also covers a fund house’s value fund and contra fund. You are free to hold any mix. But the rule shows that overlap is worth checking.

Will I pay tax if I stop a SIP in a duplicate fund?

No. Stopping a SIP is not a sale, so no tax applies. Your old units stay invested. Tax applies only when you sell units. For FY 2026-27, equity fund gains are taxed at 20% within 12 months. After 12 months, gains above ₹1.25 lakh a year are taxed at 12.5%.

Is one index fund enough for diversification?

An index fund copies a market index, such as the Nifty 50. So one fund holds many shares. For many investors, one core index fund or two to three funds with clear roles can be enough. But the right mix depends on your goal, risk level and cost. This is a general view, not personal advice.

Want Us to Check Your Portfolio Overlap?

Do you hold four or more funds? We can compare their holdings and show you the duplicates. Fill in a short form and our team in Pallikaranai, Chennai will call you.

Book a Free Financial Planning Consultation

📞 +91 91763 40301 · +91 99402 47435

Deepak Gokul, CWM, Founder of Deepak Wealth Framework, Chennai

Deepak Gokul, CWM®

Chartered Wealth Manager (CWM®) · NISM-Series-XVII: Retirement Adviser Certified · IRDAI Licensed Insurance Advisor · Founder, Deepak Wealth Framework

Deepak Wealth Framework Pvt Ltd — AMFI Registered Mutual Fund Distributor | ARN-328771

Deepak Gokul specialises in goal-based financial planning, child education planning, SIP investments, mutual fund advisory, and retirement planning for families across the globe. With his Chartered Wealth Manager (CWM®) certification and specialised training in retirement advisory, Deepak helps clients build long-term wealth through structured, disciplined financial planning.

📞 +91 91763 40301 | 🌐 deepakwealth.com | 💼 LinkedIn | ▶ YouTube | 📘 Facebook | 📸 Instagram | ✕ X | ⭐ Google Business Profile

📍 Pallikaranai, Chennai

Disclaimer: Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully. This content is for illustrative and educational purposes only. We deal in Regular Plans.

Disclaimer

Investments in Mutual Funds are subject to Market Risks. Read all scheme related documents carefully before investing. Mutual Fund Schemes do not assure or guarantee any returns. Past performances of any Mutual Fund Scheme may or may not be sustained in future. There is no guarantee that the investment objective of any suggested scheme shall be achieved. All existing and prospective investors are advised to check and evaluate the Exit loads and other cost structure (TER) applicable at the time of making the investment before finalizing on any investment decision for Mutual Funds schemes. Before making an investment, please contact the investment expert at Deepak Wealth Framework for designing a portfolio that suits your needs. We deal in Regular Plans only for Mutual Fund Schemes and earn a Trailing Commission on client investments. Disclosure For Commission earnings is made to clients at the time of investments. Option of Direct Plan for every Mutual Fund Scheme is available to investors offering advantage of lower expense ratio. We are not entitled to earn any commission on Direct plans. Hence we do not deal in Direct Plans.

AMFI Registered Mutual Fund Distributor | ARN - 328771 | Date of Initial Registration: 14/05/2025 | Current Validity: 13/05/2028.

Scroll to Top
Share via
Copy link